Scansafe is launching a new free product called scandoo which aims to tag search results with Green yellow and blow widgets so you know which sites are safe (green), dangerous (red) or uncertain (Yellow). ZDnet had news of the scandoo service which is not the first attempt at making the web safe… Siteadvisor from McAfee attempts to do the same (with installed software) and Symantec is working on a competitor as well. Further there are toolbars that attempt to protect users from phishing scams, but I’m not sure that this service will be as successful as hoped.
I’ve tried it and one thing that it relies on is the categorizing of sites. Essentially sites are tagged into categories – Here’s the list…
Arts and Culture
Fashion and Beauty
Food and Drink
Hate and Discrimination
Leisure and Entertainment
News and Magazines
Politics and Society
Sex / Nudity
Toys and Games
By default 4 categories are tagged as unacceptable (Weapons, Sex and Nudity, Illegal Activities and Hate and Discrimination) and will be marked with the red icon. You can add tags to your “unacceptable site list. Sites that haven’t been categorized are left with a yellow question mark. There are problems that I’ve seen though. For one, I’m not sure what lengths one has to go to get a site categorized. I’ve tried to tag this site as technology several times as I’m in the yellow question mark territory. I suspect that it takes their moderators intervention, or a certain number of votes perhaps. But what if a “trusted” domain tagged as Leisure and Entertainment lapses and get’s registered by a hate group? Also, it does merely tag content rather than preventing the visiting of it.
It only tags those results from the search engine. It doesn’t tag sponsored results (ads) or links once you’ve followed one page. I don’t think this will have a great impact on the number of spyware, adware, or browsers exploited. There is a note in the zdnet article that they have a browser toolbar on the way, which I suppose could be more effective in tagging sites (i.e. sites that you visit after a main search page would be tagged I hope.) However, this looks more like a possible route to a content filter than a cureall for spyware. (I didn’t see a single way that a site could be tagged as having malicious content, just categorized for content.) The truth is, it’s not just gambling/hacking/porn sites that have nasty browser exploit content.
Now, just looking at it as it is. I think it could be a good guide for someone wanting to avoid getting to the “wrong place”. For instance in a search for sex site…. it managed to tag fairly well, news and information sites as being ok, but porn sites with the red icon. (Although it didn’t prevent visiting the site, although I image with a toolbar, they might allow a system administrator to control that. So this could be a useful tool (with that added feature) with publicly collaborated tags for tightening controls on public pcs web access.)
Again, the zdnet article says it aims to reduce the risk of spyware/adware, by warning of malicious sites… in practice – not quite. I can’t tag this as “security” news then, but it might be a good content filter (or search advisor of a sort.)
Related PostsRelated Posts
- Google Music Beta news is reporting on Google Music. They say it will make it easier to find artists, album titles and lyrics. Not too long ago there was a report that the Recording industry was going to wage a war on lyric sites... Apparently Google will also provide links to music......
- More google news sitemaps.... What are they trying to prove??? Okay, Google Analytics rolled out (slowly) earlier this week and is just now catching up on reporting data. It looked like one of the rockiest initial Google releases to date. This morning came the news of Google Base a way to submit and search,......
- Is Manual Link Building For You - It May Be There are a lot of SEO methods out there. And all of which have their pros and cons and manual link building is not an exception. This is nothing more than looking for the sites that you want to link back to yours and add them to that site or......
- Earning Money With Articles And Reviews: Article Publication Sites Article Directories are sites that house free of charge content articles. These content articles are generally set there by whoever owns the copyright to them as a promotion technique. Every post has the owners byline placed under it to ensure that people who ultimately examine the post will know who......
- NJ Web Design: It Is More Valuable Than You Imagine The propensity for many people that are beginning a webpage for the first time is to not give NJ web design the attention it warrants. When nearly all people are beginning a website as a beginner, the one thing which they're concerned about is how to receive the most visitors......
- Google explains Google China Decision
- Spyware’s likely suspect sites.
- Roll your own search engine… sort of…
- Search engines to blame for malware spread?
- The wolf in sheeps clothing, software that claims to be anti-spyware, but installs more spyware on your pc