Criminal Charges against users of software that infringes on Intellectual Property?



According to cnet news. A new proposed EU law could allow criminal charges and jail time for the bosses of businesses that run software that infringes on someones Intellictual Property. SCO in the last couple of years has brought civil charges against businesses using linux claiming that linux violates their (SCO’s) IP. (Something which as of yet has not been proven.) A law like this could put doubts in peoples minds about using Open Source software (as the article is titled…. “EU Plan could put open sourcers in court”).


The proposal has not been approved. Some say it’s unlikely to see businesses pursue this kind of criminal charges against software users for fear of bad publicity. I see this concept though as a bad precedent. Let me see if I can give an example by analogy. Let’s say you see a neat and innovative shelf out in the world. It fits into corners neatly or something. You think it’s a neat idea (it’s patented of course), but decide not to buy because you think you can make something fairly close. You go home and you make something like it, but for your own personal use. You make several even. My understanding of where the law has been up until now, is that if you seel it that’s when problems arise. Frankly that’s the way it should be, steal and SELL someone else’s idea and you get into trouble. IP with software is a murkier issue it seems, but going after users of software is just a bad idea all the way around. It opens a precedent that the homebrew community (with regard to most any do-it-yourself make something like a ______ for your own use) wouldn’t like the impact of.

Here’s a novel idea. How about, if you think your software IP has been stolen, take it up with the group that’s putting the software out, PROVE the paper chain of how it got stolen and deal with it that way. On the other side of things, IP and patenting needs some major reform. I’ve seen too many laughable patents approved. (Let’s see, I’ll patent a method for presenting another page to display in response to a mouse click. Maybe I’ll call it a hyperlink, then I’ll sue anyone else making use of it without licensing it from me.) I’m afraid without major COMMON SENSE reform of patenting we’re going to be headed for a mess much worse than we see today.

Related Posts

Blog Traffic Exchange Related Posts
  • Good writeup on patents and standards There is a good posting at the zdnet blogs talking about proprietary standards and why they are not a good thing in comparison to open standards. The talk specifically mentions Microsoft Word documents as an example of a de facto Proprietary standard and then goes on into a current example......
  • Australian Linux consultancy lodges complaint against Microsoft Windows A Melbourne based open source firm has lodged a complaint with that country's Competition and Consumer Commision against Microsoft. According to The Computer Business Review online, they claim that Microsoft's monopoly is harming consumers. They are calling for 1) the availability of computers without a preinstalled operating system and 2)......
  • Sony and Amazon to buyback cds It looks as though the recall is being detailed for the Sony cds that use the XCP Digital Rights Management copy protection. Sony has setup a page where customers can request an exchange. Sony will swap cds with DRM for cds without the DRM software. Also, Amazon.com is offering refunds......
Blog Traffic Exchange Related Websites
  • Article Submitting Software Vs. Manual Submission If you are planning to submit articles for promoting your web site, there are some important things you need to consider. The major decision for you to make is whether you are going to submit your articles manually or to use article submission software. To make an informed choice you......
  • How Much Does An Appraisal Cost? I'm trying to close on an investment property in Boise and I just got the loan docs. The appraisal for a single family house thats brand new and 1966 sq ft was $850!!!!Normally they cost $350 and if you doing an investment home they sometimes charge $450-$550 , but $850......
  • Mozilla Thunderbird: Free Email Software Whilst web-based email services like hotmail and googlemail are great for personal use, they only enable you to access one email account at a time. If you want to download all your emails from various accounts into one place (like many small businesses do) , you need software installed......
www.pdf24.org    Send article as PDF   

Similar Posts


See what happened this day in history from either BBC Wikipedia
Search:
Keywords:
Amazon Logo

Comments are closed.


Switch to our mobile site